Technical Explanation
Advantages of radiant heat by Richard D. Watson
This article is reprinted from Fine Homebuilding June-July 1992
Studies conducted by the American Society of Heating, Refrigeration and
Air Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) indicate that with radiant heating
systems people can be comfortable at temperatures 6°F to 8°F lower
than with convective systems. Forced-air and baseboard (whether electric
or hot-water) heating systems are convective systems because they use
air as the primary heat-transfer medium.
Typically, heating outlets or baseboards are placed on outside
walls, and the system is designed to fill the area with warm air
until the preset temperature on the thermostat is reached. The warm
air rises to the ceiling until it cools, falling to the floor for
return to the furnace or to fill the convective vacuum created by
a baseboard heater. Air stratification and heat loss to the ceiling
are significant with convective heat.
Air is transparent to the transfer of radiant energy, which occurs
directly from warmer to cooler objects. With radiant ceiling heat,
the temperature varies only about 2°F to 4°F between the
ceiling and the floor, with the floor being about 2°F warmer
than the air. And radiant floor heating results in reverse stratification.
Humidification is unnecessary with a radiant system because radiant
heat does not alter residential air moisture content, which is generally
adequate if the air isn't dried out by combustion or by increased
infiltration of cold, dry outside air.
Glass, particularly low-e glass, reflects long-wave radiance produced
by residential radiant systems. This greenhouse effect serves to
contain radiant energy within the heated building cavity, reducing
heat loss.
Air-infiltration heat loss is reduced with radiant heat. Air infiltration
and exfiltration increase as the difference between inside
and outside temperature (ΔT) becomes larger. When superheated air
from a furnace or baseboard heater flows against relatively cold
exterior walls, the increased temperature differential results in
a stack effect that draws cold air into the house through any cracks.
With radiant systems, the air is only warmed to the temperature
of the thermostat setting (which is usually lower to start with),
so the temperature differential at the outside wall is less, thereby
reducing air infiltration.
When applied to the sizing of a radiant system, conventional heat-loss
analysis often includes a reduction in design temperature from 70°F
to 65°F and a 10% to 25% reduction in building air infiltration,
exfiltration, stratification and glass heat loss. The average 65°F
radiant comfort temperature with 59°F day/night setback should
reduce building heat load by 25% to 35% over convective systems.
Richard D. Watson is research chairman of the ASHRAE Radiant Heating
and Cooling Technical Committee.
| 
